Saturday, August 31, 2013

Great start on Thursday possible blog prompts for the Republic

Hi Everyone,

just a note to say I really enjoyed class on Thursday.  I apologize for not getting to a discussion of  death and the soul.  We'll talk a bit about  that  at the start of  class Thursday.  

Some possible  blog  posts  about  Republic  1  and  2.


Reflect on the signficance of the opening scene of the dialogue.
In what ways does Book 1  seem like a dialogue in and of itself?
Why does it matter that Socrates participates in the conversation under a certain kind of constraint?
Describe Cephalus as a person and how his views on justice reflect his personal circumstance.
Describe Polemarchus as a person  and how his views on justice reflect his personal circumstance.
Describe Thraysmachus as a person and how his view on justice reflect his personal circumstance.
How does  Socrates  treat  each of the interlocutors?
What do we learn by observing what Socrates describes about the  events?
Assess the relative merits of  each of the three definitions of  Justice.
Which characters  admit  aporia?

Why does Socrates think he is finished with the conversation after Book1?
How does Glaucon persuade him to stay.
What is the philosophical import of the ring of gyges story?
What do you think of the city and soul  analogy  as a means of finding the nature of justice?
Describe life  in the  city of necessity.
Why does Glaucon reject this city?
What is  different in the luxurious city?
What is the gist of  Socrates' gripe with Homer and the poets?

No comments:

Post a Comment